Chinese girl dies in hit-and-run that sparked outrage

BEIJING (Reuters) - A two-year-old Chinese girl run over by two different vehicles and ignored by passersby died on Friday, state media said, in a case which ignited public uproar over what some called a moral numbness seeping through society.

Both drivers who ran over the girl have been arrested, but Internet users have flooded microblogs decrying the apathy of the people who left her for dead, after graphic footage from a security camera of the incident went viral.

Wang Yue died of brain failure more than a week after the accident in Foshan in the far southern province of Guangdong, Xinhua news agency said.

"The hospital went all out and made utmost effort to save her. But ... her injuries were too severe and the treatment had no effect," Su Lei, the director of the Guangzhou Military Hospital's intensive care unit, told a news conference.

The surveillance video from the October 13 hit-and-run, aired by a television station, shows the girl run over by a van, which drives off leaving her to bleed on a narrow street.

More than a dozen people over the next seven minutes walk or drive past the girl on bicycles and she is run over by a second truck. A woman then pulls the girl to the side of the street before her mother, a migrant worker, rushes into the frame.

China's economic boom and the growing disparity between the rich and poor have made changing social values a contentious topic, with some lamenting what they see as materialism replacing morals.

"Now people have become so selfish. So many people walked by but no one helped her because they didn't want to get into trouble," said Yang Yaying, a 21-year-old Beijing resident.

Wang's death quickly became the most talked about topic on China's popular Twitter-like microblog service, Sina's Weibo.

"I hope that this little angel who was discarded by society can act as a wake-up call to the nation about the importance of moral education," wrote one blogger, "gongzai xiaoben."

"Hope you can find some love in heaven. This world is full of apathy," added "Winter space."

Xinhua said her father had received more than 270,000 yuan ($42,280) to help pay for Wang's medical treatment, with donations flowing in from Chinese people all over the world.

INTROSPECTION

A senior provincial social worker, Liu Runhua, said he did not believe the case reflected a wider malaise in Guangdong.

"Those who ignore the dying make up only a handful of people in the province," the China Daily quoted him as saying.

"But cases when dying persons aren't given help, or when good Samaritans get into trouble, are often widely reported in the media, which tends to make the public concerned."

The provincial capital, Guangzhou, plans a law to protect good Samaritans and give rewards of up to 500,000 yuan for such actions, the newspaper added.

The provincial Communist Party chief, Wang Yang, urged "searching reflection" on the incident, the official Guangzhou Daily reported.

"Take active and effective steps to raise the moral standards of the entire society," he told a meeting of province officials, according to the paper.

"We should look into the ugliness in ourselves with a dagger of conscience and bite the soul-searching bullet," Wang also said, Xinhua reported separately.

Many people in China are hesitant to help people who appear to be in distress for fear that they will be blamed. High-profile lawsuits have ended with good Samaritans ordered to pay hefty fines to individuals they sought to help.

($1 = 6.386 yuan)

(Additional reporting by Chris Buckley and Sabrina Mao; Editing by Nick Macfie)

What do you feel about this article?

682 comments

  • curlygirl 5 days ago
    GOD Bless this sweet little baby girl and bring comfort to her mother's broken heart....
    Cold heartless society
  • richardjjordan 4 days ago
    Family is everything ; YOU have to be prepared to "GO TO THE BRINK"!
  • titus.17 2 days ago
    Sadly, evolution has led to the devaluation of human life. If we emerged through a continuous process then what qualifies to be human? How differently will they behave if they are taught they were descended from animals? Our humanity does not depend on our abilities but on our heritage. We are human because we were descended from Adam & Eve. People are valuable because we bear God's image (Genesis 9:5–6).
  • Alistair Oo 4 days ago
    what is with the world these days? first a little girl is left to die, then racists decide to take advantage of this tragedy for their own goals...don't forget this could happen anywhere! RIP Wang Yue :(
  • Mae 3 days ago
    I am speechless.... People what is happening to you???
    The people who pass by cant you even think???
    Hu? What if that happens to you? What if others will just ignore you too.
    I couldn't believe it..reading and watching this article really breaks my heart..
    i agree to those people who said that they should be in jail..
    because if they have a reasons why they shouldn't well i have a reason why they should be in jail.
    1) It's crime and all the people in world knows that.
    2) All people in the world has a mind and a heart (except if your with Satan whose the cruelest of them all)
    3) It does not matter if your poor or rich THINK if your in that situation would you like people to just ignore you too.
    4) that incident is not normal the child have broken bones and lost a lot of blood and shes only 2 years old do you think she can survive. ( the mother who pass by with a child should know it too. SHE HAS A CHILD WITH HER.)

    that's all i just wish that this will wake up people in china who does not have a heart ( because not all chines are like that there are some too who has a good heart like the woman who help her.)
    May God bless you and give you a right thinking.Yueyue you're a beautiful angel.
  • sakura_tsuki 4 days ago
    As horrific as this is, just think of all the incidents that aren't captured on camera.
  • Ide Kaoru 5 days ago
    Oh no, please do not offer a reward system for being a good Samaritan. If such a reward exists, I'm afraid people with work in groups: one to cause harm on someone, and the other party to act as the good Samaritan to profit on the reward. People should act out of kindness from their own heart. Just penalize those who do not give a helping hand. That's what the CCTV's are for, to capture the wrong doings ~ both directly and indirectly!
  • dragon 4 days ago
    Seven Billion people in this world...so few human beings!
  • Purple62 5 days ago
    I found out about this a while ago, since it got out to the Chinese-language media here in Toronto on Monday. And I want to offer my condolences to the little girl's family.

    But here's where my sadness, in all honesty, turns into anger. Hit and runs are awful no matter what the exact circumstances are - whether you hit someone by accident or on purpose, show enough of a conscience to stick around and take the consequences. Please. As for the second driver...I honestly don't get it. Even if you were the most selfish person on this planet, it would still be disadvantageous for you to run over another person with your vehicle, if for no other reason than that you wouldn't want to damage your car.

    It saddens me that people refused to help because they feared getting into trouble for it - and it saddens me even more that my browser is showing me a link to a CBC article where the woman who did step in to help has to now justify that she wasn't doing it to seek her own glory. I guess that's just the way of things now, isn't it? People are used to only seeing others help them out of selfish interests...can't we accept a Good Samaritan when it comes our way?

    Finally, I want to say something about the comments I've been seeing here. While I do not agree with the actions of the drivers of either of the two vehicles or the passersby in any way, I do not think it is justified to assume that all Chinese society is like this. It's easy to reach that conclusion, yes, but how many of us have missed the fact that the article's stating that the Chinese public is outraged by this? How, then, can we say that Chinese people are all cruel and heartless and without morals? At least these people have the grace to realize there is something wrong in their own society - let's start from that.
  • rocketrisco 5 days ago
    They should throw all 18 passersby in jail. All people need to start taking responsibility for there actions!!
  • Shawna 5 days ago
    People in Beijing are busy... Are you F*$#@%g serious? That's an excuse as to know one stopped including the not 1 but two vehicles hit her?!?!?! What the hell is wrong with people? And besides that point, where the hell were her parents? She was 2!!!!!
  • DJPhins72 5 days ago
    I can't get this poor little girl out of my mind! As a father of 3 older children, I would try to save ANY child!!! Who gives a sh%^ about race. I am just so sad and heartbroken. I'm afraid if I saw that video one more time(And unfortunately I saw it once and wish I didn't), I would go balistic. What has this world come to where a hurt child is not recused or even cared for??? This world has gone to sh%^!!!! Please pray for this little one. God i would adopt her and love her. And have you seen the video of her mother. Not one tear!!! Its like she was relieved that she was gone!!! F%$^ U!!!!
  • Lala 5 days ago
    mother's broken heart??? where was the mother for the ten minutes? where was she to begin with? all those who passed by should also be arrested as they are as guilty in her death as the ones who drove over her.
  • Vincent 4 days ago
    This is a classic example of the bystander effect. It happens all the time. It's just this time, it was caught on cctv.
  • Myles C 4 days ago
    Another example of how heartless "humanity" is becoming. To say society is like putting North America on pedestal above China. This and much worse happens in your own backyards as well.
  • Nick E 5 days ago
    Three disgusting facts:

    1) the fact that a truck chose to run over a 2-year old child instead of waiting for the child to move off the street (its fairly clear at the start of the vid that this wasn't an accident and that the truck simply ran her over to get her out of the way)

    2) the 18 or so people that simply ignored a bleeding/severely injured child on the street

    3) another truck that simply ran over the child again as this was the easiest way to proceed down the street

    Individually, each of these acts is horrendous, together, absolutely sickening. I have completely lost faith in humanity. I don't want to live on this planet anymore.
  • Tisha 5 days ago
    I couldnt imagine my son being hit by a car and then be ignored. This just breaks my heart into a billion pieces. What little faith I have in society is dwindling with the events of the past few weeks but this just takes the cake.

    How can people be so cruel? I feel so terrible for the parents that have to wake up every day and never hear their daughter say "good morning" all because people were scared to get in trouble. Parents, hug your babies extra tight tonight and send out some love to this sweet little angel who had no right to be robbed of life so young
  • Sam 5 days ago
    You are all a little heartless also...a baby died...who cares where she is from or her country's politics...she died...Yue Yue died..It is sad, it should be sad for everyone...
  • Joe 4 days ago
    The moral compass of the world has sadly swayed. Greed and selfishness has taken away from the basic principles of life---treat others how you would want them to treat you. I wonder how those passerby's would feel being left in the street to die. Shame on all of us.
  • Fed Up Chick 2 days ago
    This comment is similar to the one from climbingirl from Vancouver, B.C.

    I was in Alberta one winter, and it was so cold that my car’s battery died in the middle of a very busy road.

    Cars went by speeding, and some drivers even had the guts to yell at me to get out of the road.

    I had no where to go, the tow trucks were totally busy towing cars because it was -50.

    45 minutes after my car got stalled, a good French Samaritan guy came out of his car, and helped me get out of the road at least.

    I was so shocked to see the other side of our society. I think I saw the worst of our precious country that day.
    However, it is that 1% who will always make up the difference.

    This guy was cursing and infuriated at how the rest of the drivers acted.

    8 years after, that good Samaritan is still in my heart, and he is always in my prayers.

    Welcome to one of the most humble and kindness cities in Canada, Edmonton, Alberta.

    You my friends, can see that it is not only in China, it happes in our backyards too.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT