Elektronische musik: a guide to krautrock

It might be more than 30 years old, but krautrock, Germany's experimental music from the 1970s, still has a freshness that sixth-generation British indie bands can't match

Faust
Devil's music ... Faust. Photograph: Murdo Macleod

It began out of nothing, was given a joke name, and became the pop influence du jour: krautrock, kosmische musik, elektronische musik, or whatever you wish to call German experimental rock from the 1970s. Cited and adapted by artists as diverse as Q-Tip, the Horrors (whose epic Sea Within a Sea convincingly updates that Neu! motorik), Foals, Deerhunter, even Kasabian and Oasis (but don't let the last put you off).

The list is so long as to be almost meaningless, but a new Soul Jazz compilation, Elektronische Musik, reinforces just how wild German music from that period was. It also raises the question of why kosmische musik, which has impacted on pop for the last 30 years (just think of Afrika Bambaataa, Brian Eno and David Bowie, to name but three), is still so popular today.
 
It began out of the revolutionary student movement of 1967 and 1968: one strand formed communes and became political activists, others began to attempt a new German music that was not schlager, the mainstream music of the day. Their quest was given added impetus by the fact that many of these war babies knew their history had been erased. They had nothing, but that meant freedom.

This was their year zero. Informed by Karlheinz Stockhausen, the Mothers of Invention, the Velvet Underground and Pink Floyd, among others, the late 1960s and early 70s saw the formation of many key groups: Can, Faust, Amon Düül II, Organisation (later Kraftwerk), Guru Guru and Tangerine Dream, many of whom were released on German labels such as Ohr and Brain.
 
There are several DVD bootlegs covering this early period, as well as YouTube clips and the actual albums. What they record is a balls-to-the-wall experimental approach that takes ideas, feelings and competence as far as they can go, and then further. There are no limits. This first-time delirium continues the psychedelic upsurge of 1966-67 but gives it a tougher edge: it was, as Julian Cope wrote, "soaringly idealistic and hard as nails".

It was Cope's Krautrocksampler, published in 1995, that first organised and codified a history of "the great kosmische musik". Cope focused on the first wave of groups, many of whom were popular in England thanks to the visionary Andrew Lauder, who released Can and Amon Düül II on United Artists. (Then there was the 49p issue of The Faust Tapes.)

Since this groundbreaking study, the floodgates have opened; but the Soul Jazz compilation opens out the genre even further. If you go into the affiliated Sounds of the Universe shop in Soho, you'll see a rack for experimental German music alongside all the reggae 7"s, funk/disco 12"s, dubstep, free jazz and cosmic disco CDs. Put together by Stuart Baker and Adrian Self, the Elektronische Musik compilation totally fits that free-booting eclecticism.

It begins with Can's A Spectacle, sampled by Q-Tip on Manwomanboogie (from his 2008 album The Renaissance). There are the usual suspects: Faust, Neu!, Cluster – the last represented by the track Heisse Lippen, from their best album, Zuckerzeit – but there is a greater reliance on funky beats/breaks, and you get long improv epics such as High Life by Ibliss. The second disc ends with the blissed-out drones of Deuter's Soham, a higher-key masterpiece.

The implication is that there is more here than you ever thought. German music from this period is a bit like the Tardis: you got through a narrow portal into a huge, dynamic space. Kosmische's fertility is only matched by its desire to create something totally new, and it is that which has proved inspirational to successive generations of musicians from right across the spectrum.

Its increased resonance in the 21st century comes from the fact that Anglo-American rock has a six-decade history and has been thoroughly cannibalised. Tired of sixth-gen Brit indie groups? Sick of Americana apologists? Then let kosmische be your guide. Starting from nothing but their imagination, the 70s German groups continue to offer a third way: a long, straight road out of this cultural impasse.

Elektronische Musik is out 5 April on Soul Jazz


Your IP address will be logged

Comments in chronological order

Comments are now closed for this entry.
  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

  • DaveXPat DaveXPat

    30 Mar 2010, 12:32PM

    Horrible dirge: the only thing it's good for is sampling the "best bits" and leaving the rest well alone. It's where it belongs, way back in the 20th century. American apologists indeed. Silly ol' John.

  • dothebathosphere dothebathosphere

    30 Mar 2010, 12:34PM

    Nice article Mr. Savage - but...

    German music from the mid nineties onwards was pretty damn good too (someone else will have to speak up for the Neubauten / Pyrolator / HNAS generation in between) - so there's a bigger picture than a single late 60s, early 70s golden generation. As 'Post-rock' or whatever, the nineties and beyond stuff was as good as the best of America and UK lot.

    Silly list - top notch stuff:
    Oval
    Couch
    Kreidler
    AGF/Laub
    Tarwater
    Microstoria
    Ms John Soda
    Mouse on Mars
    To Rococo Rot

    Not quite personal favourites, but:
    Lali Puna
    Alec Empire
    The Notwist
    Carsten Nicolai and the Raster Noton scene
    10^8 techno records...
    ... others

    If Soul Jazz want me to compile a survey album, I think I could waiver my fees.

  • richardrj richardrj

    30 Mar 2010, 12:44PM

    Savage is spot on here regarding the krautrock groups' being influenced by late '60s acid and psych rock. Kosmische apologists, and even some of the bands themselves, often make the spurious claim that they were getting away from Anglo-American rock altogether. Whereas in fact they owe a clear debt to Floyd, the Dead etc.

  • BaronCharlus BaronCharlus

    30 Mar 2010, 2:24PM

    There are illicit PDFs of KRS available in various online spaces. It's a riot. Cope clearly took the 'when in doubt, publish the myth' adage as gospel.

    Some of the records are incredibly hard to track down through legitimate sources without resorting to buying deleted cds on eBay for upwards of twenty pounds. Maybe Rhino could do a reissue series.

    My current fave rave is Tarot, by Walter Wegmuller: 'Du bist de Narr!'

  • Dostoyevsky01 Dostoyevsky01

    30 Mar 2010, 2:31PM

    DaveXPat - you are so wrong. Listen to Can in particular - this band more than any other shaped the way I perceive music.

    @jforbes- I just bought a copy of Cope's book - claiming to be an English version (ok not a first print) - off ebay. The seller had two remaining.... just thought i'd poss on the news.

  • TheNoiseOfCarpet TheNoiseOfCarpet

    30 Mar 2010, 2:45PM

    I'm disappointed that no reprint of Krautrocksampler seems planned. The JRocksampler was a blast and opened up my ears to the incredible Les Rallizes Dénudés. Cope, if it needs revising, get on with it!

  • digit digit

    30 Mar 2010, 3:01PM

    @dothebathosphere

    (someone else will have to speak up for the Neubauten / Pyrolator / HNAS generation in between)

    Yes. That's a buck I'll pass too. Nice list, dtbs.

    'I am Damo Suzuki!' If Krautrock was what it took to get us to The Fall, then, darnit, it's OK by me.

  • BaronCharlus BaronCharlus

    30 Mar 2010, 3:02PM

    @NoiseOfCarpet

    Afraid Cope has explicitly stated that he will not reprint CRS. He sees his role as being a champion of outsider or 'unsung' music. As soon as it gains mainstream attention, as krautrock has done, he moves on, not wanting to be pigeonholed.

    Of course, much as I love him, he could also get over himself and republish the bloody book.

  • speedkermit speedkermit

    30 Mar 2010, 3:07PM

    Contributor Contributor

    Cope's book was a bit patchy I thought. Anyone wanting a good survey of 'Kosmische' should check out Wire's Primer in Issue #308. I prefer the wibbly-ambient end of the Krautrock spectrum personally, Harmonium and Cluster especially, although anyone who doesn't like Can is tired of living. I want Uphill played at my funeral.

  • ColonelLegal ColonelLegal

    30 Mar 2010, 3:07PM

    This comment has been removed by a moderator. Replies may also be deleted.
  • scraggs scraggs

    30 Mar 2010, 3:09PM

    I'm not sure it's worth engaging in debate with someone who casts off a playful, boundary-pushing, wholly influential and (something often ignored) hugely diverse genre of music as a "horrible dirge".

    Love so much about Krautrock and also about the bands who were influenced by its spirit as much as the various elements which defined its sound (eg The Fall).

    I saw Cluster recently, and they sounded both stately and contemporary. The real deal.

  • Kalyr Kalyr

    30 Mar 2010, 3:18PM

    I'm not sure it's worth engaging in debate with someone who casts off a playful, boundary-pushing, wholly influential and (something often ignored) hugely diverse genre of music as a "horrible dirge

    ".

    Especially when "show all by" reveals that person to be a huge fan of three-chord indie-rock.

  • Self Self

    30 Mar 2010, 3:21PM

    'Good blog - just wish Mr Cope would reprint his book as I'm not going to pay £100 for it!'

    100 pounds?! I should have bought two. Must get some insurance.

  • CorduroyEnthusiast CorduroyEnthusiast

    30 Mar 2010, 3:25PM

    Was listening to Agitation Free's superb "Malesch" on the way to work this morning, wonderful stuff...and they weren't even half a Popul Vuh, Can or Faust. (Be warned though, I went to see Harmonia last year...they were disappointingly awful).

    Agree with scraggs...the best Krautrock was brilliant, it is not great to criticise it because of a large number of untalented chancers (I suppose one could adapat Sturgeon's law to this?). The problem was that as the scene became prominent, third-rate hard rock toss was pushed as being "Krautrock" to lend it credibility.

    There's also a strand of underground music in the US at the moment that draws (or rips-off...depends on your prejudice!) heavily on Kosmiche music. Emeralds are a particular favourite of mine. In fact, there's so much that's great - Jooklo Duo (or whatever they are calling themselves, depending on who/how many they are working with - I seem to recall they did something with Japanese Krautrock fetishising (this is good) band Acid Mothers Temple) who are essentially jazz made a record last year that was incredibly kosmiche/kraut.

    And to think I got into Can because of The Stone Roses and the Happy Mondays (to a lesser extent Sonic Youth, although that the time SY were a little more on the periphery for me...changed now...student union discos kinda ruined the Roses and the Mondays for me).

  • buntyman buntyman

    30 Mar 2010, 3:45PM

    Scraggs, did you see them with Tortoise? That was great.

    Interesting piece, there was a good documentary on bbc4 a while ago which featured a priceless anecdote about Can and David Niven, I wont spoil it though as its bound to be repeated.

    I had the honour of playing with Damo a year or so ago at the railway inn, winchester, amazing fun. Then we got him drunk/stoned and made him breakfast the next day. You couldnt hope to meet a nicer rock icon.

  • FragileAwareness FragileAwareness

    30 Mar 2010, 3:54PM

    Good call buntymen, the documentary on bbc4 was great, especially enjoyed Damo's contribution. Got into krautrock after seeing him play a semi improv set with various Melbourne luminaries when I was in Oz last year, was amazing and I've never looked back.

    Looking forward to seeing Faust at Pavement ATP and Damo Suzuki acolytes should note that he's playing 3 dates at the Kilburn Luminaire with six bands from May 2-4th I think. Definitely going to try to get along to one of them.

    The Liars have a pretty good updated take on Krautrock particularly on the 'Drum' not Dead' album weirdly omitted from all the 'best of the noughties' polls.

  • eprstockholm eprstockholm

    30 Mar 2010, 4:29PM

    Be warned - Zuckerzeit is far from Cluster's best album. Not even close

    I'd agree with that: I think it's dated really badly and been superseded by a lot of other electronic music... much of it from Germany, which has been the epicentre of most electronic genres over the last decade or so.
    I really like the earlier Cluster albums, especially the spaced-out Cluster 71.

    I can see, to an extent, where the "interminable prog" comments are coming from and there are some bands - Amon Düül II, for example - who just bore or disinterest me, sounding worrying like the kind of dull American hippy jam bands most of their fans would dismiss instantly, but things like Can, Faust, Neu! and Harmonia have a hell of a lot more to offer, and are more diverse than they're often given credit for (well, maybe not Neu!, but they did do their one trick exceedingly well).

    And the best thing is that there is just so damn much of it out there, with myriad solo projects and obscurities: personally, I've only really dipped my toes in.

  • Spare Spare

    30 Mar 2010, 4:34PM

    I dearly love this stuff, particularly the more electronic end of the spectrum. But let's be honest: Krautrock as an influence on pop is really REALLY 1990s. What was post-rock but a hundred bands finally getting their hands on NEU! bootlegs? All right, that's a bit reductionist, but you get the idea.

    I'll continue to replay my Can albums, but can we all move on? Maybe those hundred bands could get their hands on some old Rock In Opposition and really send SmokyBarnacle around the bend.

  • maybeperhapsyes maybeperhapsyes

    30 Mar 2010, 4:37PM

    Kosmische apologists, and even some of the bands themselves, often make the spurious claim that they were getting away from Anglo-American rock altogether. Whereas in fact they owe a clear debt to Floyd, the Dead etc.

    I think this is overstated actually. Many of the most seminal Krautrock bands owed much more to German & French composers experimenting with electronica from the 30s through to the 70s, as indeed do the Beatles, Floyd etc themselves. A cursory listen to Messiaen Schaeffer Varese Stockhausen etc will verify this.

  • francoisP francoisP

    30 Mar 2010, 4:40PM

    It's just teutonic prog.

    Thanks for the insighful comment

    Interesting piece, there was a good documentary on bbc4 a while ago

    It was very good, there is also the DVD Kraftwerk and the Electronic revolution featuring early Kraftwerk, and their contemporaries, though there is more talking than music on it

    Hallogallo by Neu! is a classic

  • tinylittlebear tinylittlebear

    30 Mar 2010, 4:47PM

    I saw Damo Suzuki live in a pub near me. I live in a town where not much happens, but this was possibly the best gig i've ever seen. Absolutely amazing. Then I went to a party at someone's house and I sat having a chat with him. Best night of my life.

  • matthewkalman matthewkalman

    30 Mar 2010, 4:54PM

    Weren't there two big/comprehensive Krautrock guides out, some years back - much bigger than Cope's wee book? (Glad I have a copy, reading all the comments here!).

    One of the Krautrock books was by the guys that run the 'Ultima Thule' krautrock/experimental etc shop up in Leicester - named after a Tangerine Dream single, I think.

    I recently noticed that some folks seem to be running regular sessions in a church in Crouch End (?), listening to kraut classics, by Popul Vuh etc.

    That sounds like a really obsessive and slightly bizarre thing to do.

    Shame I can't make it along ;-)

    I'm trying to work out what my kraut fave is. Gila's 'Free Electric Sound' is great ('best album Pink Floyd never made').

    I guess I currently like the Kosmische Folk-type stuff - the good bits on Emtidi's Saat, Holderlin's first. Maybe Sergius Golowin/Cosmic Jokers' 'Lord Krishna von Goloka' fits here too. (The good bits of Tarot).

    And you can't beat the electronica of Hoenig, Ashra, Schulze et al...

    Even when the krauts do heavy rock, it's great - eg Gomorrha ? I turned to See Whose Voice It Was. Well, some of it. (NB of course, somewhat crappy German singers bring down the odd album, here and there).

    And there's all that slightly more jazzy stuff too, Embyro, Kollektiv...

    Oh, and there's Yatha Sidhra - where's that fit. Just very cosmic indeed ;-)

    Cope always has such a great turn of phrase, the prog band Yes as "artless dry w*nk" ;-)

    Almost every album seems like finding the Holy Grail, the way Jules tells it!

    Has he managed the same with Jap-rock...?!

    On his Head Heritage website, Cope delves quite far into the rock vaults - lots of long-forgotten bands, most of it heavy rock related. Read the reviews.

    I finally got round to checking out the Groundhogs, thanks to Cope.

    He certainly makes it easier to be 30 or 40 years behind the times ;-)

    Thanks Julian! :-)

    Matt

  • Thackur Thackur

    30 Mar 2010, 5:04PM

    I love the fact that when you listen to Hero by Neu! you realise where Mark E Smith, John Lydon and Shaun Ryder all nicked their vocal styles from.They're three of the most individual and instantly recognisable vocalists the UK has produced, but they each in their own way got there by trying to mimic a shouty German bloke.

  • FuriousOrange FuriousOrange

    30 Mar 2010, 5:07PM

    Don't care for most of the "Krautrock" groups mentioned except for CAN. The haunting drums and bass of Yoo Doo Right from the Monster Movie album, the eery and hypnotic guitar playing of Michael Karoli on Mother Sky from Soundtracks and the strange and mysterious Soup from Ege Bamyasi. Future Days and Soon over Babaluma were light years ahead of Pink Floyd and were a huge influence on Brian Eno's awesome ambient albums. My favorite is still Tago Mago which contains Halleluhwah, Aumgn and Peking O, still some of the most original, strange, bewildering and exhilarating music I have experienced. As for Faust and Amon Düül II, they pale into dull insignificance when compared with the almighty Can.

  • matthewkalman matthewkalman

    30 Mar 2010, 5:11PM

    Another thought, is 'Zeuhl' music - Magma, Weidorje, Laurent Thibault, Zao et al - unpopular/forgotten/brilliant enough for Cope to do a book on it?

    I'd buy it!

    But he's probably a bit snooty around jazz influences, and the lack of unstructured freak-outs and bad singing... ;-)

    Boy would I love to have a copy of Jean-Philippe Goude's 'Drones'. I even contacted Goude himself, who thought it was in print from Musea (?), when it wasn't...

    Matt

    PS Cope's concert at the Royal Festival Hall where he got Gottsching and Schulze back together - if I remember correctly - was great.

  • MacauBlue MacauBlue

    30 Mar 2010, 5:14PM

    Blimey! So much here that I missed first time around! I always loved Kraftwerk, Can, then some Einstürzende Neubauten and recently Lali Puna but seems as though I barely scratched the surface! Better get delving!

    Thanks for the blog Mr Savage!

  • PhelimONeill PhelimONeill

    30 Mar 2010, 5:20PM

    Contributor Contributor

    Been rediscovering the solo albums of Michael Rother (Neu! Harmonia) recently, the ones he did in the 70's with Jaki Leibziet. Flammande Herzen is one I'd wholeheartedly recommend, it's easily available and very accessable - Rother was allegedly Bowie's first choice for his Berlin stint, although his second choice, Robert Fripp, was hardly slumming it. It does sound like they used a lot of the same tech as Low but the music is so light and spacey.

  • DiagonalArgument DiagonalArgument

    30 Mar 2010, 5:56PM

    Couldn't agree more. My personal favourite is the Gravlax reissue of Iklam Bernigoth's 1975 masterpiece 'Bentfingers', worth buying for the bonus tracks alone. One of them, entitled 'Schelpgeist" sees Bernigoth attempt to find a G note by hitting a spade in various places. It's 12 minutes long.

    Also, I'm surprised nobody has mentioned outstandingly influential Krautrock pioneers Jib Forte. One could write an entire book on their side projects alone. Who can forget where they were when they first heard Gobschmuck Avaplast? Or the essential Toktok with its droning pedal steel guitar played through a pedal made from an electric glockenspiel?

    Of course, no genre is without its sour notes, and I think we can all agree that the tiddlywink blip-bloppage of Justice Klempner is best left on the shelves.

  • scraggs scraggs

    30 Mar 2010, 6:06PM

    buntyman

    30 Mar 2010, 3:45PM

    Scraggs, did you see them with Tortoise? That was great.

    No, I wasn't present for that. Einstellung were on the bill with them.

  • andyw23 andyw23

    30 Mar 2010, 6:33PM

    Cope's book was great in that it introduced a new generation to the music, but his account of the history and background is pretty thin and not to be taken seriously in any way. The graphics are nice, though :-) The Ultima Thule book is great for obsessives (like myself). There was also a recently published book on Krautrock by Black Dog Publishing and, dare I say it, my own book 'Faust: Stretch Out Time' offers a lot of background and historical analysis apart from the chapters devoted specifically to Faust. The Kraftwerk DVD is excellent in almost every way - even if you aren't a fan of Kraftwerk themselves, most of it is taken up with interviews, film and analysis of the scene across Germany that produced them.

    Perhaps the reason that krautrock has gained increasing attention over the years is that it was so radical in its time that it has taken almost 40 years for the rest of the world to catch up. Indeed, records like Faust's first are still way out in front of mainstream groups like Radiohead in terms of sheer sonic adventure (I'm not picking on Radiohead for any reason other than that in the mainstream press they count as being somehow progressive or adventurous).

    And to the person who described Krautrock as 'just prog' - well, yes, some of the music that gets recycled today as 'krautrock' is nothin more than that - but groups like Faust, Neu!, (early) Cluster and Zohl Caravan are more like some unholy fusion of avant-classical music and punk than anything prog could have imagined (give or take Henry Cow).

  • NorthGoingZax NorthGoingZax

    30 Mar 2010, 6:36PM

    Interminable concept based noodling. It's just teutonic prog

    How much did you listen to to reach this insighful view?

    Kosmische apologists, and even some of the bands themselves, often make the spurious claim that they were getting away from Anglo-American rock altogether. Whereas in fact they owe a clear debt to Floyd, the Dead etc.

    Can't say I agree, yes there might be something of a debt but that doesn't mean they weren't trying to move away from the Anglo-American rock of the time, the accent on simplicity & repetition runs completely counter to what prog was all about.

    Another vote for Michael Rother's solo albums, very much on the ambient laid back end of the spectrum but utterly georgous much like the first half of Neu75.

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

Comments are now closed for this entry.

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.

Music blog weekly archives

Mar 2010
M T W T F S S

Latest news on guardian.co.uk

Guardian Bookshop

This week's bestsellers

  1. 1.  Music and Sentiment

    by Charles Rosen £16.99

  2. 2.  Electric Eden

    by Rob Young £17.99

  3. 3.  Listening to Van Morrison

    by Greil Marcus £12.99

  4. 4.  Cover Art of ECM

    by £50.00

  5. 5.  Ginger Baker

    by Ginger Baker £7.99